Skip to main content

Table 3 Natural exosomes versus synthetic liposomes as advanced drug delivery systems

From: Bioengineered exosomal-membrane-camouflaged abiotic nanocarriers: neurodegenerative diseases, tissue engineering and regenerative medicine

Properties

Exosome

Liposome

References

Structure

Naturally enriched with lipids, proteins, and nucleic acids

Composed of lipids, but no proteins and nucleic acids are present

[119]

Origin

Biological origin (naturally released by cells)

Synthetic origin (bottom-up approach)

[119, 120]

Complexity of contents

Heterogeneous composition (low control of contents)

Homogeneous composition (high control of contents)

[119, 120]

Polydispersity

Polydisperse

Monodisperse

[120]

Drug loading capacity

Low loading efficiency; both hydrophobic and hydrophilic drugs can be loaded

High loading efficiency; both hydrophobic and hydrophilic drugs can be loaded

[18, 121]

Immunogenicity

Absent (high biocompatibility)

Shows immunogenicity

[120, 122,123,124]

Targeting features

Natural organotropism (ascribed to binding proteins expressed on surface membrane)

Low organotropism per se (surface ligands must be added for improving cell targeting)

[119, 120, 127]

Cell internalization

Cell uptake occurs via several well-established mechanisms

Cell uptake occurs via non-established mechanisms

[120, 128, 131]

Ability to cross biological barriers

Present

Absent

[129]

Systemic half-life

Short half-life (approximately 60 min after administration*)

Reduced half-life (incorporation of PEG can confer stealth features)

[132, 133]

Industrial scale production

Very challenging (clinical-scale production methods are missing)

Easy clinical-scale manufacturing

[120, 134]

  1. PEG polyethylene glycol
  2. *Although it has been suggested that exosomes are rapidly cleared from bloodstream after administration, studies are reporting that blood circulation of CD47-expressing exosomes can be substantially improved